Compliance guide What is review gating, and is it allowed?

Review gating looks like a clever shortcut to a better rating. It breaks Google policy, can breach consumer law and is easy to avoid while still hearing from unhappy guests first.

Updated 8 November 2026 · By the Stars team at FlexiWork

The short answer

Review gating is asking customers how their experience went and then only inviting the happy ones to leave a public review, while steering unhappy ones to a private form. Google prohibits it, because selectively soliciting positive reviews distorts ratings. In the UK, publishing reviews in a misleading way is a banned practice under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, and in the US the FTC treats suppressing negative reviews as unlawful. The compliant alternative is to collect private feedback and keep the public review option open to every customer.

Key takeaways
  • Gating = deciding who gets the review link based on how happy they are.
  • Google prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews and discouraging negative ones.
  • UK and US consumer law treat hiding or suppressing negative reviews as misleading.
  • Private feedback is fine, as long as every customer can still leave a public review.
  • Never tie an offer or reward to leaving, changing or removing a review.

What review gating looks like

A typical gated flow asks “How was your visit?” with stars or smiley faces. Customers who pick four or five stars are sent to Google or Tripadvisor. Customers who pick one to three stars are sent to a private complaint form and never shown the public review option.

Other versions include only emailing review requests to customers the staff picked as happy, or hiding the review link behind a screen that only positive answers can reach. The result is the same: the public rating no longer reflects all customers.

Google’s position

Google’s policies for reviews prohibit businesses from discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews and from selectively soliciting positive reviews from customers. Google also prohibits incentives in exchange for reviews. Reviews that Google considers manipulated can be removed, and Google can restrict a Business Profile from receiving new reviews.

UK law: the DMCC Act 2024

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 added fake reviews to the list of commercial practices that are always unfair. Since 6 April 2025 it has been banned to commission or publish fake reviews and to publish consumer reviews in a way that is misleading, which includes suppressing or hiding negative reviews. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) can now enforce consumer law directly and fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover. The CMA’s guidance on fake reviews explains what businesses must do.

US law: the FTC rule on reviews

The Federal Trade Commission’s rule on the use of consumer reviews and testimonials took effect in October 2024. It bans fake reviews, incentives that depend on a review being positive, and review suppression, such as using threats to stop negative reviews or presenting the reviews on your own site as all or most of your reviews when negative ones were left out. The FTC can seek civil penalties for knowing violations. Several states have their own consumer protection rules too.

How to collect feedback without gating

  • Keep the review link open to everyone. Every customer who gives feedback can still choose to leave a public review, whatever their rating.
  • Make private feedback an addition, not a filter. The point is to hear about problems quickly, not to stop them being public.
  • Ask every customer. Do not pick who receives review requests based on how you think they feel.
  • No conditions. Recovery offers, refunds and gestures of goodwill must never depend on leaving, editing or removing a review.
  • Check your tools. Ask any feedback or reputation vendor exactly what the customer sees after a low rating.

How Stars handles it

Stars was built without review gating. Guests leave private feedback by QR code or link, and a low rating alerts a manager so they can reply and recover the guest. Public review links stay available to every guest, and recovery offers are never conditional on leaving a review. You can start a 14-day free trial and see the guest flow yourself.

Frequently asked questions

Google prohibits it on its platform. In the UK, hiding or suppressing negative reviews is a banned practice under the DMCC Act 2024 from April 2025, and in the US the FTC rule on consumer reviews prohibits review suppression. The exact legal risk depends on how the gating is done, so the safest approach is not to gate at all.

Only if the answer decides who sees the public review option. If every customer can still leave a public review whatever rating they give, collecting private feedback is not gating.

Google can remove reviews it considers manipulated and can restrict a Business Profile from receiving new reviews for a time. It may also show a warning on the profile.

No. Choosing who receives review requests based on whether you expect a positive review is selective solicitation, which Google prohibits. Send requests to all customers or to a neutral sample.

Yes, as part of putting a problem right. The offer must not depend on the customer leaving, changing or removing a review.

Related guides

Recover the guest. Prove the return.

Hear it first. Fix it fast. Win the guest back.

Private QR feedback, instant manager alerts, one-time recovery offers and Google review replies, for £39 a month.